A report from Livelaw News said that the court raised this question while hearing a batch of petitions challenging the Centre’s 2021 notification, according to which OCI students are entitled to apply only to NRI seats in NEET admissions
The Supreme Court last Tuesday November 29 asked children of Overseas Citizens of India (OCI), who are staying in India, to apply for Indian citizenship after giving up their foreign citizenship.
A report from Livelaw News said that the court raised this question while hearing a batch of petitions challenging the Centre’s 2021 notification, according to which OCI students are entitled to apply only to NRI seats in NEET admissions.
Senior Advocate K V Vishwanathan, appearing for the petitioners, submitted that he was representing students, who were born to OCI parents, and had been residing in India. He stated that OCIs can’t be compared with Non-Resident Indians (NRIs), as the NRIs were living abroad and were earning in foreign currency. However, many OCI families were staying in India.
“They have comeback and their children have completed their studies till 12th here and suddenly a notification in 2021 says you will be on par with the NRIs and will not be able to apply for general seats or All India Quota even though they fulfil the domicile requirement,” the senior lawyer submitted.
At this juncture, the bench comprising Justices AS Bopanna and Sudhanshu Dhulia wanted to know why the OCI persons were staying in India. Vishwanathan explained that OCI was a concept introduced by the Government of India in 2005 to confer certain rights to persons of Indian origin, who may have foreign citizenship, so that they are encouraged to settle in India and give their services here. In some cases, children may have got foreign citizenship when they were born abroad while their parents were working there, and they might have returned to India later. They might have grown in India, but have the OCI status due to their foreign citizenship. Hence, it would be illogical to compare them to NRIs, who have been practically living outside India.
-
OCI PLEA: “The NRIs earn in dollars or other foreign currencies. But the OCI parents here earn in Rupee and pay tax. But their ward is OCI, who is now treated as NRI as per the 2021 notification. The flipside is that they can’t go to a college in foreign countries as they are not considered a home candidate”
-
UNION GOVERNMENT PLEA: OCI petitioners were trying to compete in the seats meant for Indian citizens, who have no avenues outside, whereas, the OCI students can get citizenship rights abroad
-
SUPREME COURT: Commenting that medical seats were a “scarce commodity”, Justice Dhulia asked Viswanathan (OCI Lawyer) “Why don’t you give up the citizenship there… and apply for Indian Citizenship.”
At this point, Justice Bopanna commented about the practice followed by some people, whereby the delivery of the child is planned in such a way so that it takes place in a foreign country where automatic citizenship is granted on birth. “But later, they will face problems like this. You are neither there nor here. You are stuck,” Justice Bopanna commented.
“Why don’t you get Indian citizenship here?” Justice Dhulia asked.
Vishwanathan replied that a decision regarding citizenship can be taken only after a person attained the age of majority and most of the students applying for admissions were minors. He pointed out that the percentage of NRI seats in medical admissions was too little less and the fees for such seats was exorbitant, which could not be afforded by OCI students living in India.
“The NRIs earn in dollars or other foreign currencies. But the OCI parents here earn in Rupee and pay tax. But their ward is OCI, who is now treated as NRI as per the 2021 notification. The flipside is that they can’t go to a college in foreign countries as they are not considered a home candidate”.
Advocate Kanu Agarwal, appearing for the Union Government, requested for adjournment as the Solicitor General and Additional Solicitor General were engaged in another hearing. The Union’s counsel added that the petitioners were trying to compete in the seats meant for Indian citizens, who have no avenues outside, whereas, the OCI students can get citizenship rights abroad.
Commenting that medical seats were a “scarce commodity”, Justice Dhulia asked Viswanathan, “Why don’t you give up the citizenship there?”
In reply, Vishwanathan submitted that the petitioners were not asking for the conferral of any new rights but the continuation of the benefits which were being given till 2021. In this regard, he referred to Section 7B of the Citizenship Act 1955, which stated that the OCI persons were entitled to the rights specified by the Government. Since the rights had been in existence for long, there was a legitimate expectation and the sudden withdrawal of the rights was arbitrary, he argued. Many OCIs chose to settle in India on the basis of the rights conferred under Section 7B. The Centre’s notification was painting all OCIs with the same brush, without considering persons who have been residing in India for long.
*********************************************************************
Readers
These are extraordinary times. All of us have to rely on high-impact, trustworthy journalism. And this is especially true of the Indian Diaspora. Members of the Indian community overseas cannot be fed with inaccurate news.
Pravasi Samwad is a venture that has no shareholders. It is the result of an impassioned initiative of a handful of Indian journalists spread around the world. We have taken the small step forward with the pledge to provide news with accuracy, free from political and commercial influence. Our aim is to keep you, our readers, informed about developments at ‘home’ and across the world that affect you.
Please help us to keep our journalism independent and free.
In these difficult times, to run a news website requires finances. While every contribution, big or small, will makes a difference, we request our readers to put us in touch with advertisers worldwide. It will be a great help.
For more information: pravasisamwad00@gmail.com
