Monday, December 23, 2024

The story behind the real origin of “Har, Hara Shambhu” and the Controversies that still follow it

28-year-old Muslim singer, songwriter, social media influencer, YouTuber, entrepreneur and Indian Idol contestant Farmani Naaz from Mohammedpur Mafi village in Muzaffarnagar district of Uttar Pradesh, claims  she is the original singer and composer of this powerful bhajan

 

Conflicting claims and counter claims abound across the internet and beyond  over a popular bhajan “Har, Hara, Shambhu”, that has stormed the internet and garnered close to over 100 million views on You Tube.

On the one hand, Orissa-born Jeetu Sharma (26 years), claims he is the original writer, composer and singer of the bhajan. His duet with classical-trained Oriya singer Abhilipsa Panda (18 years, born November 30, 2004) of this bhajan, has received over 80 million views over You Tube.

On the other hand there is 28-year-old Muslim singer, songwriter, social media influencer, YouTuber, entrepreneur and Indian Idol contestant Farmani Naaz from Mohammedpur Mafi village in Muzaffarnagar district of Uttar Pradesh. 

She maintains she is the original writer, composer and singer of “Har, Hara Shambu”. Within weeks of singing her version of this bhajan, she has been able to earn a following of over 10 million viewers on her You Tube channel.

Angered and upset by her bhajan, the Muslim   clergy and hardline elements within the community were quick to point out that singing and music are against the fundamental tenets of Islam and is regarded as ‘haram’  

As a result of the anger and the outcry raised by them, You Tube thought it better to discontinue playing the bhajan on their site in the larger interest of communal harmony and peace.

But this has in no way dampened Farmani’s spirits. She stands firm and unafraid, solidly backed by all her family members and most people in her village. 

She says: “Creative persons and artistes, especially performing artistes, express their love for the creator through music, and this devotion is far and above all religious laws and edicts, which tend to divide rather than unite people in an amicable bond of love and harmony”. 

Bollywood singer, the late Mohammed Rafi, could sing hundreds of bhajans for  films and private albums, why must a single bhajan by Farmani raise eyebrows and generate so much heat, anger and controversy.

But there is a much more interesting side to “Har, Hara Shambhu”, that extends far beyond the shores of India. 

In an interview to the media, both print and news channel, singer Jeetu Sharma admits that originally the musical composition for his bhajan, actually comes from a Krishna bhajan. 

It had been previously written, composed and sung by a Grammy Award nominee and Black American singer, Acyuta Gopi, a devout Hindu and a follower of ISKCON (International Society for Krishna Consciousness). 

He says when he was working on the lyrics of “Har, Hara Shambhu”, he was absolutely blown away by the catchy, musical composition and powerful singing of Acyuta Gopi’s  song “Har, Hara  Krishna”. 

But there is a much more interesting side to “Har, Hara Shambhu”, that extends far beyond the shores of India. In an interview to the media, both print and news channels, singer Jeetu Sharma admits that originally the musical composition for his bhajan, actually comes from a Krishna bhajan singer in the United States, Acyuta Gopi. 

As if drawn by some powerful magnet, Sharma could not resist the idea of immediately writing to Acyuta, seeking permission to use her musical composition for his bhajan. 

Acyuta Gopi very kindly and graciously agreed to allow Sharma to use her music as the tune for his bhajan.

More about Farmani Naz

Adverse circumstances often become the strongest drivers of change along that steeply uphill and ragged road to success, riches and fame. 

Farmani’s case is no different. The eldest of four siblings, she was born into a life of extreme poverty to farm labourer Mohammed Arif and Fatima, her parents. Arif just about manged to eke out a living as a daily wage earner and keep life ticking along at a subsistence level.  

In such a situation, education was the biggest casualty and Naz had to discontinue her studies after Grade 8. A short-lived marriage in her early teens to Imran, from Hasanpur village in Meerut district, only brought her more suffering, forcing her return to her parents’ home with her three-year-old son.

A congenital defect in her son’s throat turned her husband and in-laws against her who wished to have nothing to do with her. Back in her village, Naz started out to earn a living, doing the only thing she knew best – Singing. 

Her beautiful, crystal-clear voice became her strongest ambassador and harbinger of good times. After, Ashu Bachchan a performing artiste from her village posted a video of her singing a popular song by Lata Manageshkar on his You Tube channel, she became an overnight celebrity.

That first music video has her singing Lata Mangeshkar’s song “Milo Na tum Toh Hum Ghabraayein” as she paints her house. The video recorded over 9.4 million views. Farmani has also got a chance to record a song with singer Kumar Sanu. 

Now there is no looking back and today she owns her own recording studio worth more than a crore of rupees. Her brother Farman, is also a gifted singer and features in most of her music videos.

 

*********************************************************************

Readers

These are extraordinary times. All of us have to rely on high-impact, trustworthy journalism. And this is especially true of the Indian Diaspora. Members of the Indian community overseas cannot be fed with inaccurate news.

Pravasi Samwad is a venture that has no shareholders. It is the result of an impassioned initiative of a handful of Indian journalists spread around the world.  We have taken the small step forward with the pledge to provide news with accuracy, free from political and commercial influence. Our aim is to keep you, our readers, informed about developments at ‘home’ and across the world that affect you.

Please help us to keep our journalism independent and free.

In these difficult times, to run a news website requires finances. While every contribution, big or small, will makes a difference, we request our readers to put us in touch with advertisers worldwide. It will be a great help.

For more information: pravasisamwad00@gmail.com

David Solomon
David Solomon
(For over four decades, David Solomon’s insightful stories about people, places, animals –in fact almost anything and everything in India and abroad – as a journalist and traveler, continue to engross, thrill, and delight people like sparkling wine. Photography is his passion.)

Related Articles

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

- Advertisement -

EDITOR'S CHOICE