Reddit debate highlights growing dilemma among Indian-origin residents in Canada over dual identity, family planning, and long-term mobility
A lively debate on Reddit’s Ask NRI forum has spotlighted a complex question facing thousands of Indian-origin residents in Canada — whether to pursue Canadian citizenship or retain their Indian passports. The dilemma blends emotion, practicality, and long-term planning, with many now exploring what’s being called a “split strategy, reported businesstoday.in.”
The couple outlined three possible paths: both taking Canadian citizenship, both retaining Indian citizenship, or adopting the “split strategy” — one spouse becoming Canadian while the other remains Indian.
“We want to maximise flexibility for our child’s future, ideally giving them options for both Canadian and Indian citizenship,” the couple wrote. “We’re leaning toward the split strategy but wanted to hear from others who’ve been in a similar situation.”
The conversation began when an Indian couple living in Canada, eligible for citizenship, shared their plan to have their first child there but possibly return to India in a few years — raising questions about identity, inheritance, and future opportunities
Their considerations included taxation, pension benefits, property rights, and education costs in India. While Canada’s passport allows visa-free travel to over 180 countries, India’s refusal to allow dual citizenship forces families to make an either-or decision.
‘Split Strategy’ Gains Momentum
The idea of dividing citizenship between spouses resonated with many users as a practical balance between global mobility and maintaining Indian legal rights.
“I understand the split strategy to save fees for your child, but you don’t have a child yet,” one Redditor cautioned. “Traveling in Asia on a Canadian passport is far more hassle-free than with an Indian one. Airline staff treat you differently — it’s a noticeable shift.”
One U.S.-based commenter shared how a flight delay in Frankfurt exposed the difference:
“She wasn’t allowed to leave the airport while I was. Stuck for eight hours in a small area — it changed her mind. A Canadian passport can even help overcome subtle class or caste barriers in India.”
Others clarified misconceptions about Overseas Citizen of India (OCI) privileges, noting that while OCIs can inherit and buy flats or commercial property in India, they cannot purchase agricultural land or vote.
Emotional vs Practical Trade-offs
Several commenters reflected on how family priorities evolve after settling abroad. “Ask yourself why you want to move back,” one user advised. “I planned to leave for the UAE after getting citizenship, but after my daughter was born, the natural environment and access to everything made me stay.”
While many acknowledged the sentimental pull of the Indian passport, most agreed that Canadian citizenship offers significant advantages — from ease of travel and global recognition to stronger consular support. Yet, for those maintaining close ties with India, OCI restrictions and property rules remain frustrating hurdles.
A Balancing Act for Modern Migrants
The discussion captures a broader tension among the Indian diaspora, especially for young families balancing career growth, property investments, and cultural belonging.
For many, the “split strategy” provides a middle ground — allowing one partner to secure international benefits while the other maintains access to Indian rights. But as one Redditor succinctly put it:
“No matter what you choose, there’s always a trade-off — between emotional belonging and practical convenience.”
